Filed under: Breaking, Conservatives, Government, House, Media, Progressives, Rights, Senate | Tags: Civil Liberties, Congress, FISA, House, Intelligence, Rights, Senate
The FISA debate is underway in the House of Representatives; you can watch it on CSPAN here.
The issue is whether or not to grant retroactive immunity to telecommunications companies who helped the Bush administration spy on the American people without warrants, in violation of federal laws.
The current proceedings have been as follows:
- The House passed an immunity-free bill, H.R. 3773
- The Senate passed a bill with immunity in it, S. 2248
- The Senate stripped out the text of H.R. 3773 and substituted in the text of S. 2248, then sent the amended H.R. 3773 back to the House
- Conyers and Reyes have an amendment to H.R. 3773 (as amended by the Senate) that would strip out what the Senate put in (the text of S. 2248) and put in its place the new, immunity-free language.
The GOP is muddying the waters with their usual rhetoric and spin–they talk about patriotic companies doing their duty and keeping America safe by cooperating with the government’s orders.
Of course, ignore the fact that the government was breaking the law, and the telecomm companies went along with it. Ignore the fact that the domestic spying program hasn’t lead to a single terrorism-related conviction or arrest. And ignore the fact that these companies weren’t following the government and doing their duty–in fact, when the federal government didn’t pay their phone bills on time, the telecomm companies shut the wiretaps down.
The telecomm companies and the Bush administration broke the law, and now their enablers in Congress are resorting to tired fear-and-smear tactics to beat their critics into submission and to make themselves exempt from the law.
For centuries, our country has protected itself from threat after threat without stripping away our Constitutional rights. We protected ourselves from threats far greater than terrorism without stripping away everything that makes this country great. And in the end, accountability matters. Our rights matter. The law matters. And it’s time for the secrecy to end.
More as it comes…
UPDATE: They’re voting now on the Senate amendment. With 6:00 left in voting time, the yeas lead the nays 109-69.
UPDATE II: In another attempt to destroy oversight and prevent themselves from being held accountable, the Bush administration recently gutted the Intelligence Oversight Board, which was established in the wake of the Nixon administration to prevent the abuse of intelligence agencies and personnel.
On the House floor, with a minute left in voting, the yeas lead the nays 150 to 126.
UPDATE III: Voting just closed; the yeas lead the nays 161 to 139. The vote totals are still shifting.
UPDATE IV: Vote totals are still changing; right now, 196 yeas to 171 nays. Awaiting the final vote totals.
UPDATE V: Final vote totals: 213 yeas, 197 nays and 1 present. The motion denying retroactive immunity passes; a motion to reconsider is laid on the table.
UPDATE VI: Here are the final vote totals on the bill. No Republicans voted yea, while a number of Democrats voted nay. The Democrats who didn’t vote in favor of the bill are below:
| Dan Boren | (D-OK) | (202) 225-2701 |
| Mike Capuano | (D-MA) | (202) 225-5111 |
| Chris Carney | (D-PA) | (202) 225-3731 |
| Bob Filner | (D-CA) | (202) 225-8045 |
| Maurice Hinchey | (D-NY) | (202) 225-6335 |
| Tim Holden | (D-PA) | (202) 225-5546 |
| Dennis Kucinich | (D-OH) | (202) 225-5871 |
| Nick Lampson | (D-TX) | (281) 488-4922 |
| Jim McDermott | (D-WA) | (202) 225-3106 |
| Heath Shuler | (D-NC) | (202) 225-6401 |
| Pete Welch | (D-VT) | (202) 225-4115 |
| Lincoln Davis (Voted Present) | (D-TN) | (202) 225-6831 |



